He’s Been Dating Her For 4 Years. She Wants a Decision on Marriage. What Should He Do?

Unless the answer is a screamingly obvious “no,” I’m not sure if there’s a more difficult question to answer than, “Should I marry this woman?”

How did you know you found “the one”? My (30F) girlfriend of 4 years is asking me (33M) to decide if I want to get married in the next couple months.

Like the title says, my girlfriend has asked me to decide if I want to marry her in the near future, mostly for biological (family starting) reasons. I understand where she’s coming from, so I’m working to make a decision as fast as I can, and have taken time off work (have a high stress, long hours job that leaves little space for deep personal thought) to do as much thinking as I can about it. I know that will sound strange to most, but I’m a pretty analytical person and I want to bring the best decision making possible to any big decisions like this.

She has many of the “macro” things that I want – good family, smart, similar ambition and life direction, etc.. but I find friction in our day-to-day interactions which causes me some concern and makes me wonder how happy we’d be together forever. I’m not sure it’s worth trying to describe all the pros and cons I see and have people evaluate it, but I am curious to get perspective on a few broad questions:How did you know you found the one?

Trending: He Watched 9 Guys Run a Train On Her & Then Later Married Her

What traits did you find most important when selecting your long term partner?

How do you weigh the importance of “macro” things like life direction vs “micro” things like humor?

Were there any tools/resources you found helpful when making a commitment decision like this?

Other advice or suggestions for someone in my situation?

First of all, I’ve known multiple women in this situation. Just to name a couple that come to mind — one was 10 years into a relationship, desperately hoping for marriage, and… years later, it still hasn’t happened. Another was 5 years in and had her boyfriend teasing engagement, but he wouldn’t pull the trigger. She dumped him over it and a couple of years later was married to another guy and popping out kids.

Out of the two, I think the 2nd woman was smarter. Along similar lines, I don’t think it’s the least bit unreasonable for a 30-year-old woman who has been dating a guy for four years to want to know where he stands on marriage. If the answer is, “no,” she can ditch him now and try to find a guy while she’s still fertile.

As to whether this guy should marry her or not, that question is almost impossible to answer since he has given so little information. That being said, if you are four years into a relationship and are still on the fence about whether you should marry a woman, it says something. It’s also worth noting that he seems to think they align well on things like family and life goals, while his concerns are about their day-to-day interactions. Since marriage is in one sense a neverending string of day-to-day interactions, that could be a problem.

In any case, if he ultimately decides that he doesn’t want to wife his girlfriend, given her age, the kindest thing he could probably do would be to end it rather than dragging her deeper into her thirties in a relationship that is never going to pan out for her.

Previous articleFeminist: ‘Manspreading has crossed over to the realm of running, and it’s not OK’
Next articleWhen It’s a Bad Idea For a Man To Try to Live a ‘Balanced’ Life
John Hawkins
John Hawkins created Rightwingnews.com in 2001; built it up to a top 10,000 in the world website; created a corporation with more than 20 employees to support it; created a 3.5 million person Facebook page; became one of the most popular conservative columnists in America; was published everywhere from National Review to Human Events, to Townhall, to PJ Media, to the Daily Wire, to The Hill; wrote a book 101 Things All Young Adults Should Know that was at one point top 50 in the self-help section on Amazon; did hundreds of hours as a guest on radio shows, raised $611,000 in a GoFundMe for Brett Kavanaugh’s family and has been talked about everywhere from The New York Times to Buzzfeed, to the Washington Post, to Yahoo News, to the Rush Limbaugh Show, to USA Today. After seeing the unjust way that Brett Kavanaugh was treated during his hearings and how a lifetime worth of good work was put at risk by unprovable allegations, John Hawkins decided to create a men’s website. Welcome to Brass Pills!


Join the conversation!

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spam, instead of replying to it please hover over that comment, click the ∨ icon, and mark it as spam. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.